• your Windows® embedded community

    eWEEK Windows for Devices - Your Windows Embedded Community

    Windows For Devices

  • home
  • news
  • embedded PCs
  • boards
  • handhelds
  • tablets
  • thin clients
  • enterprise
  • consumer
  • articles

    News

  • Home > News

        Windows vs. Linux in embedded: the debate continues

        Doug | Date: Jun 30, 2006 | Comments: 1



        • Print PDF
        • Filed Under: News

        Responding to an article at ZDNet that discussed the prospects for Linux in future mobile phones and other embedded devices, John Carroll, programmer and Microsoft employee, blogs that Windows CE has a lot going for it too, and is now the "de facto standard in handhelds."




        The original ZDNet article focused on the "five C's -- complexity (or rather, lack of it), control, customization, cost and community," said to be working in Linux's favor.

        Carroll, a regular ZDNet blogger, notes in his retort that with most of the source code released under a Shared Source license, customization is no longer an issue with Windows CE. And since Shared Source does not require modifications to be shared, it's a better deal for vendors wishing to maintain their code as proprietary.

        Carroll adds a sixth "C" -- consistency. He points out that Linux in the mobile space is even more fragmented than it is on the desktop, and that's no way to build applications that require native access. "Ecosystems in software demand consistency, particularly if they compete with ecosystems that have a high degree of it," Carroll writes.

        He makes a number of other interesting points. Read Carroll's complete blog post over at ZDNet:

        The Microsoft embedded freight train.




        Related stories:
        • SPECIAL REPORT: Study says embedding Windows costs less than embedding Linux
        • Concerns about embedded Linux
        • Embedded Windows vs. Linux debate continues . . .
        • Bsquare confirms EMF's findings on Windows Embedded project costs
        • Ballmer weighs in on Windows vs. Linux
        • Symbian, Microsoft, Linux scuffle over burgeoning smartphone market
        • Microsoft debuts its answer to SourceForge: CodePlex
        • HOT TOPIC: Shared source
        • Microsoft overhauls, simplifies Shared Source licenses
        • Understanding Microsoft's new, simplified Shared Source licenses
      • Newsletter
      • RSS
      • Twitter
      • Got a Tip?
      • Linux Devices

    most read

    • ARM Windows 8 may nix desktop
    • Autonomous robot's built around a Windows Phone handset
    • Intel ships Cedar Trail Atoms
    • America's first 'WhiteFi' network goes live
    • USB security device includes Windows Embedded Standard 7

      WfD showcase archives

      • Mobile Phones
      • PDAs and other handhelds
      • Netbooks
      • Windows tablets, UMPCs, and MIDs
      • Audio/video entertainment devices
      • Thin client terminals and devices
      • Voice over IP devices
      • SPOTlight on .NET Micro Framework (MF)
      • SPOT-light on Microsoft's "SPOT" Technology
      • Other smart devices

  • eWEEK Quick LInks
  • Home
  • Windows & Interoperability
  • Mobile & Wireless Technology
  • Application Development
  • Enterprise Applications
  • Enterprise Networking
  • Desktops & Notebooks
  • Technology Videos
  • ZDE Corporate Site
  • Linux for Devices
  • Microsoft Watch Blog
  • Migration Expert Zone
  • Smarter Technology
  • ASP Free
  • Scripts
  • Tutorialized
  • Technology Resource Library

Site Map

Use of this site is governed by our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

Copyright ©1996-2010 Ziff Davis Enterprise Holdings Inc. All Rights Reserved. eWEEK and Spencer F. Katt are trademarks of Ziff Davis Enterprise Holdings, Inc.
Reproduction in whole or in part in any form or medium without express written permission of Ziff Davis Enterprise Inc. is prohibited.